HDGeant4 Meeting, June 2, 2020
Tuesday, June 2, 2020
3:30 pm EDT
BlueJeans: 968 592 007
- Review of minutes from the last Meeting (all)
- Issues on GitHub
- Pull Requests on GitHub
- Action Item Review
Present: Alex Austregesilo, Sean Dobbs, Colin Gleason, Mark Ito (chair), Igal Jaegle, Naomi Jarvis, Richard Jones, Susan Schadmand, Justin Stevens, Simon Taylor, Nilanga Wickramaarachchi, Beni Zihlmann
There is a recording of this meeting on the BlueJeans site. Use your JLab credentials to get access.
Review of minutes from the last Meeting
We went over the minutes from May 19 without much discussion.
Issues on GitHub
We reviewed some of the issues.
- Issue #152: BCAL Photon Gun Updates. Mark Dalton posted a new single photon gun study for the BCAL. He sees good agreement between G3/HADR1, G3/HADR4, and G4. Sean will close this one.
- Issue #149: BCAL structure in E/p distributions for kaons. This is the issue through which we discovered the problem with using the CUTS card. Mark will ask Peter Pauli to close this one.
- Issue #143: BCAL reconstructed energy sometimes broken on startup: multicore only. Sean has been able to reproduce the problem with the particle gun. Igal also reported seeing the problem when running a single π0 particle gun. Richard will look into this one again.
- Issue #111: Difference in Acceptance between G3 and G4. We reviewed the plot Colin posted since the last meeting showing comparisons of timing for various particle types in the BCAL and FCAL. The comparison for π−s looks to have a significant contamination from protons. Colin is going to pursue a systematic study of these quantities as a function of momentum. He will also discuss with Richard a custom branch of hdgeant4 that does not register energy in the BCAL for low energy neutrons and alpha particles.
- Issue #93: Calorimeter timing mismatch between g3 and g4. We decided that the problems first raised in this issue are essentially the same as those being dealt with in Issue #111 (mentioned above). We decided to mark this one closed and refer to #111 as a continuation of exploration of this issue.
Bethe-Heitler Generator in HDGeant4
Richard has added his Bethe-Heitler event generator directly into HDGeant4 so that events that reflect the coherent bremsstrahlung beam, including polarization effects, can be simulated. He has taken care with execution efficiency, insuring that events occur in the liquid hydrogen target and including adaptive importance sampling of the phase space for the QED reaction. He has written a HOWTO on how to run the new generator.
Event Vertex Simulation
Alex initiated a discussion of Pull Request #156: add beam_spot center to the printout at initialization. On that pull request, he reported inconsistent results when intentionally moving the event vertex position in the x-y plane for a simulation and plotting the resulting beam spot after reconstruction. The beam spot appeared to move back to (0, 0). This pointed to a bug in the tracking where the final step of translating coordinates from a reference frame with the origin at the (possibly shifted) beam spot back to the global coordinate system was skipped. See halld_recon Issue #381. This has likely affected some of our reconstructed data.
The beam position in the x-y plane is retrieved from the CCDB with the current VERTEX card scheme. Alex noted that vertex positions are also obtained during reconstruction launches of the data. It is not clear which determination to use or if even if there is enough difference between them to matter. We briefly discussed ideas on how to deal with the situation. It will require some more discussion.
Action Item Review
- Ask Peter Pauli to close Issue #149 (Mark)
- Study timing in the FCAL and BCAL as a function of momentum. (Colin)
- Create a custom branch of hdgeant4 that does ignores energy from low-energy neutrons and alphas. (Colin, Richard)
- Close Issue #93 and reference Issue #111 as a continuation of the work. (Mark, Alex)
- Discuss a scheme for setting the event vertex position in the x-y plane in simulation. (all)