Difference between revisions of "OWG meeting 4-Apr-2008"

From GlueXWiki
Jump to: navigation, search
m
m (Text replacement - "http://argus.phys.uregina.ca/gluex" to "https://halldweb.jlab.org")
 
(6 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 5: Line 5:
 
* Progress on EMU and other DAQ components - Graham H
 
* Progress on EMU and other DAQ components - Graham H
 
* Status of 200 kHz front-end triggering test and 250 MHz trigger system test - various
 
* Status of 200 kHz front-end triggering test and 250 MHz trigger system test - various
* Preparation for May 2008 subsystem review, [[Online Major Milestones]], etc. - all
+
* Preparation for [[May 2008 Subsystem Review]], [[Online Major Milestones]], etc. - all
  
  
Line 14: Line 14:
  
 
==Announcements==
 
==Announcements==
 +
 +
Subsystem review likely early in May, perhaps the week of 7-May-2008!
  
  
Line 26: Line 28:
 
==Minutes==
 
==Minutes==
  
Attendees:
+
Attendees: E.Wolin, Simon T, Dave A, David L, Alex S, Carl T, Ben R, Graham H, Elke A, Dave D, Chris C, Fernando B, Jim S, Elton S.
 +
 
 +
 
 +
'''DAQ Report'''
 +
 
 +
Graham gave a brief update on the status of DAQ projects and writing assignements.  He will give a full report on the EMU next meeting.
 +
 
 +
* EMU (Event Management Unit) is basic CODA3 building block that accepts input data, transforms it, then sends the result out.
 +
* Many utilities can be built from EMU:  EB, ER, etc.
 +
* EMU framework, XML config, and diagnostic interface completed.
 +
* Code for moving data ready, but needs integration into EMU framework.
 +
* EB part not ready, butsome testing using earlier prototypes successful.
 +
* EMU build thread parallelizable for multi-core environment.
 +
* DAQ group has organized writing assignments for subsystem review docs.
 +
* Doc for each component plus top-level doc planned.
 +
* Dave D asked if a "hardware switch architecture" is preferable to a "divide-and-conquer" strategy, i.e. do all rocs talk to all EB's, or are the rocs divided up among the EB's.  DAQ group consensus was to divide-and-conquer at the roc level, although the other strategy could work.
 +
 
 +
 
 +
'''250 MHz L1 Trigger Test and 200 kHz Front End Triggering Test'''
 +
 
 +
* TI may not be ready by review, so no 200 kHz crate triggering test, but can present design and architecture.
 +
* Libs for board readout done, so some tests can be performed.
 +
* No new 250 MHz testing planned, what we have now is what will be presented.  More tests by end of this fiscal year.
 +
* Plans for additional prototyping and testing by Sep, but not for May review.
 +
 
 +
 
 +
'''May Subsystem Review'''
 +
 
 +
Elke gave an overview of what to expect at the review, and showed a preliminary agenda.
 +
 
 +
* Final pre-brief material will be placed on Elke's official subsystem review page.
 +
* Preliminary pre-brief and other material will be place here:  [[May 2008 Subsystem Review]] (needs reorganization...).
 +
* Since other detectors reviewed already (exc. tagger later this summer) no detectors will be reviewed in May.
 +
* Minor discussion on ordering of topics on agenda, length, who will give them, etc.
 +
* Still need charge and committee.  Rolf E. is handling this.
 +
* Separate Hall D and Hall B reviews the same week, with the same reviewers, is planned (I pity the reviewers...).
 +
* Seems like one day is too short, likely will go with a 1 1/2 day review.
 +
* May need some specialized talks in addition to the general ones on the preliminary agenda.
 +
 
 +
 
 +
'''L1 Trigger'''
 +
 
 +
Please read Dave Doughty's writeup on the [https://halldweb.jlab.org/DocDB/0010/001017/001/HallD_Level_1_OverviewV2.pdf level 1 trigger] and send him comments.
 +
 
 +
 
 +
'''Electronics Wiki Page'''
 +
 
 +
Fernando has begun placing information on the [[Electronics]] section of the Hall D wiki.  He is adding many links to docs and other things.
 +
 
 +
 
 +
'''Electronics Cooling'''
 +
 
 +
We had a long discussion on crate and rack cooling in Hall D. 
 +
 
 +
* Do we need water-cooled racks, or additional heat exchangers on the platforms?
 +
* Is ambient air cooling combined with redirection of hot air away from racks sufficient?
 +
* There is plenty of chilled water available (at the wall) in either case.
 +
* Hall B is successful with heat exchangers on the platforms, no water-cooled racks.
 +
* Water-cooled racks would require a below atmospheric pressure system, with pumps.
 +
* Elton says the cost for heat exchangers is included in the infrastructure budget.
 +
* Typical chilled-water heat exchangers are about $1800 each (from Carroll Jones, plant services).

Latest revision as of 12:40, 14 March 2017

Agenda


Time/Location

2pm Fri 4-Apr-2008 CC F326


Announcements

Subsystem review likely early in May, perhaps the week of 7-May-2008!


Next Meeting

2pm Fri 11-Apr-2008 CC F326


New Action Items from this Meeting

Minutes

Attendees: E.Wolin, Simon T, Dave A, David L, Alex S, Carl T, Ben R, Graham H, Elke A, Dave D, Chris C, Fernando B, Jim S, Elton S.


DAQ Report

Graham gave a brief update on the status of DAQ projects and writing assignements. He will give a full report on the EMU next meeting.

  • EMU (Event Management Unit) is basic CODA3 building block that accepts input data, transforms it, then sends the result out.
  • Many utilities can be built from EMU: EB, ER, etc.
  • EMU framework, XML config, and diagnostic interface completed.
  • Code for moving data ready, but needs integration into EMU framework.
  • EB part not ready, butsome testing using earlier prototypes successful.
  • EMU build thread parallelizable for multi-core environment.
  • DAQ group has organized writing assignments for subsystem review docs.
  • Doc for each component plus top-level doc planned.
  • Dave D asked if a "hardware switch architecture" is preferable to a "divide-and-conquer" strategy, i.e. do all rocs talk to all EB's, or are the rocs divided up among the EB's. DAQ group consensus was to divide-and-conquer at the roc level, although the other strategy could work.


250 MHz L1 Trigger Test and 200 kHz Front End Triggering Test

  • TI may not be ready by review, so no 200 kHz crate triggering test, but can present design and architecture.
  • Libs for board readout done, so some tests can be performed.
  • No new 250 MHz testing planned, what we have now is what will be presented. More tests by end of this fiscal year.
  • Plans for additional prototyping and testing by Sep, but not for May review.


May Subsystem Review

Elke gave an overview of what to expect at the review, and showed a preliminary agenda.

  • Final pre-brief material will be placed on Elke's official subsystem review page.
  • Preliminary pre-brief and other material will be place here: May 2008 Subsystem Review (needs reorganization...).
  • Since other detectors reviewed already (exc. tagger later this summer) no detectors will be reviewed in May.
  • Minor discussion on ordering of topics on agenda, length, who will give them, etc.
  • Still need charge and committee. Rolf E. is handling this.
  • Separate Hall D and Hall B reviews the same week, with the same reviewers, is planned (I pity the reviewers...).
  • Seems like one day is too short, likely will go with a 1 1/2 day review.
  • May need some specialized talks in addition to the general ones on the preliminary agenda.


L1 Trigger

Please read Dave Doughty's writeup on the level 1 trigger and send him comments.


Electronics Wiki Page

Fernando has begun placing information on the Electronics section of the Hall D wiki. He is adding many links to docs and other things.


Electronics Cooling

We had a long discussion on crate and rack cooling in Hall D.

  • Do we need water-cooled racks, or additional heat exchangers on the platforms?
  • Is ambient air cooling combined with redirection of hot air away from racks sufficient?
  • There is plenty of chilled water available (at the wall) in either case.
  • Hall B is successful with heat exchangers on the platforms, no water-cooled racks.
  • Water-cooled racks would require a below atmospheric pressure system, with pumps.
  • Elton says the cost for heat exchangers is included in the infrastructure budget.
  • Typical chilled-water heat exchangers are about $1800 each (from Carroll Jones, plant services).